27/08/10 23:25
This is the article that was printed in the Niagara Falls Review, Friday August 27th, 2010.
“Blood lust vs. tradition”
Mixed martial arts versus traditional martial arts. There are many differences, instructors say.
"It's fulfilling the blood lust. It's a pure competition for money gain," Mario Quiquero says of MMA, one of the fastest growing sports on its way to legalization in Ontario. "It's misleading of what true martial arts is."
Quiquero, a sensei at Seido- Kan Karate School on Morrison St., said MMA is more about violence than the values and philosophy of traditional martial arts.
"We preach discipline, confidence -- peace and calm," he said. "We just want to get along in this world. Peace and harmony. We all have the ability to fight ... but we don't need to break bricks with our heads or be a freak show."
Quiquero has 38 years of professional, full-time martial arts experience. He is a 7th-degree black belt and has taught in universities and held seminars around the world.
The school provides stretching exercises and aerobics, and teaches anyone four and older about co-ordination, balance, self esteem and how to have fun through martial arts.
"I'm not attacking (MMA), I'm just observing it," he said. "We have to be diverse to a certain point. It is coming to Ontario. It's just these poor guys are being recognized in the wrong places. If they walk into a pub, they're heroes and everyone wants to buy them a drink, but if they walk into parliament, no one knows who they are."
Rob Atalick, chief instructor at Niagara Kung Fu Academy on Fourth Ave., said he doesn't support MMA, but he's also not "dead-set against it.
"If people want to do it, that's fine," he said. "But they're not doing martial arts itself. It's for entertainment value."
Atalick said his club, which trains anyone from children to seniors, is about personal development, both physically and mentally. The primary style of kung fu Atalick focuses on is that of praying mantis, which he believes is the most effective for self defence.
"In MMA, you're trying to go in there and beat up someone. In martial arts training, you're looking to better yourself and others around you. There's a lot of different elements to martial arts and if fighting is in your top five, then you really have the wrong idea. It should really be about etiquette, health, control of one's environment and control of stress. Fighting should always be a last resort."
Carmine Battagli and his eight-year- old son Nicolas are students at Niagara Kung Fu Academy.
"Kung fu gives you a sense of inner strength. It teaches you patience. It's not about going out and fighting. I don't want (Nicolas) beating people up. He's a soft-hearted kid and he always tries to help people. But with kung fu, you grow together. It's a part of your life."
Deborah Toth, chief instructor at the Niagara Falls Martial Arts Center on Victoria Ave., said she doesn't support MMA and it saddens her there's a market for it.
"I see it as only glorified violence," she said. "It's also unfortunate that they call it mixed martial arts. The Ultimate Fighting Championship (the largest and best-known MMA organization) calls itself UFC. I can respect that.
"The public, however, has this misconception that the UFC and MMA are actually about martial arts. They're not highly trained in martial arts. They're highly trained in fighting."
Toth said at her karate facility, students first and foremost learn self defence, pickng up strategies and the different aspects of protection.
"You're able to take that training home and better deal with day-to-day life," she said. "A true master will tell you that a karate man that hurts another human being ... was a failed martial artist."
She said another difference between traditional martial arts and MMA is that an MMA competitor's fighting career is often short, which is usually not the case for old-school martial arts students.
"I've been training for 29 years and I'm better this year than the year before," said Toth, a 4thdegree black belt. "Masters can train right until the end."
Here is my letter to the editor regarding this.
MMA : It is a Martial Art
Regarding the article “Blood lust vs tradition” in Friday’s paper, I feel there were some misconceptions about MMA put forth by local martial arts instructors that need to be addressed.
Mixed Martial Arts IS a system of martial arts that encompasses skills in stand-up, clinch and ground. It has been proven to be the most complete system for self defense as well. For someone to say that it is not martial arts just because they do not like it is irresponsible.
The UFC is a sport where the system of mixed martial arts is used. They are two separate entities. People do not “train UFC”, they train in mixed martial arts to “compete” in the UFC.
To say MMA is more about violence than the values of martial arts is just ignorance. That is an insult to anyone who participates in MMA, which includes professionals such as doctors, lawyers and local police officers.
Mixed Martial Arts and traditional arts do have some things in common, the most important being both teach students to avoid confrontation if at all possible. Leading people to believe that MMA students would rather fight in a self defense situation than try to get away, again, is ignorance.
One of the instructors was quoted as saying “They’re not highly trained in martial arts. They are highly trained in fighting.” I would disagree with this. We are as highly trained in martial arts as some of the “masters” from the article are. It is pure ignorance of them and insulting to infer that I or anyone in my shoes is highly trained in “fighting” simply because we enjoy a martial art other than “traditional”.
If anyone is “saddened” there is a market for MMA, that is easy enough to fix. Don’t watch it.
Rich Beaupit
Owner / Head Coach
Beaupit’s Mixed Martial Arts
I was limited to 300 words or less for this letter. This weekend I will offer a very detailed rebuttal to the nonsense these highly trained instructors put forth.